Number Resource Society
AFRINIC out-of-region use: your customers, your business
AFRINIC’s manual has one sentence on use outside its region, in a rationing begun in 2017; ARIN’s allows it. Where a member’s customers are is its business.
On this page
An IP address is a number in a record, and a number has no region to be out of. “Out-of-region use” is a registry’s phrase for a network that serves customers in another part of the world, which is what networks do. AFRINIC’s policy manual has one sentence on it, among the conditions of a rationing whose first phase began on 31 March 2017. Cloud Innovation, one of AFRINIC’s members, answers nine questions on AFRINIC out-of-region use, with each rule in its own words.
For AFRINIC’s members the phrase is not academic. Every network serves customers, and a network’s customers are wherever its service reaches: across a border, on another continent. A registry that made their location a condition could tell any member whom it may serve. Where a network’s customers are is the network’s business, and its customers’.
What out-of-region use means
It is a registry’s name for using an address outside the area that registry serves. The phrase assumes that an address belongs to a region. It does not: an IP address is a number in a record, and it works because every network in the world accepts that one network uses it and no other. The 1992 document that first proposed regional registries, RFC 1366, gave the reason for them: registries in different parts of the world “may be better able to serve the local community in terms of language and local customs”. A region tells a network which registry to apply to. It says nothing about where that network’s customers are. The network that runs on an address owns it, and the registry keeps the book: Own your IP. The argument is made in full on CircleID: IP for Africa, Not Africa for AFRINIC: An IP Address Has No Continent.
The one sentence in AFRINIC’s rules
AFRINIC’s policy manual has one sentence on use outside its region. Section 5.4.6.2 reads: “AFRINIC resources are for AFRINIC service region and any use outside the region should be solely in support of connectivity back to the AFRINIC region.” It stands in the manual’s section on rationing the last IPv4 addresses, which opens by saying what it covers: “the management of address space that will be available to AFRINIC after the current IPv4 pool is depleted”. The sentence is one of the conditions for receiving addresses “during the Exhaustion Phase”. By AFRINIC’s own account, the first phase of that rationing “started on the 31st of March 2017”. A condition for receiving addresses in that phase is not a rule on every member’s network.
Cloud Innovation’s addresses predate that rationing
By AFRINIC’s own published statistics, the four blocks Cloud Innovation holds were allocated in July 2013, December 2014, December 2015 and September 2016, before that rationing began.
Must AFRINIC addresses be used in Africa?
No rule of AFRINIC’s says so, beyond that one condition on addresses rationed since 31 March 2017. AFRINIC’s management accused a member all the same. Its letter to Cloud Innovation of 23 June 2020 named the soft-landing policy, AFRINIC’s name for that rationing, as the exception. For a general rule it pointed to the bylaws: most of the member’s addresses, it said, were not used inside AFRINIC’s region, “as required by section (6) of the AFRINIC Bylaws”. Section 6 sets out who may become a member. As Cloud Innovation replied on 13 July 2020, it “does not specify anything in regards to the manner or location of usage”.
The case was built from the member’s own records. The letter says its charges came from “an examination of the utilisation records registered in the AFRINIC WHOIS database”: records Cloud Innovation had entered itself, assignment by assignment, and at one point its updates made up about 80% of all the updates to that database. The management set those records against the routing table, judging where an address is used by the country in which a network’s AS number is registered. Between that country and where an address is used, Cloud Innovation replied, “there is no reliable or meaningful correlation”.
In 2021 the management, and then AFRINIC’s Board, moved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership, which would have taken away the addresses its customers’ networks run on. The Supreme Court of Mauritius restrained AFRINIC from ending it three times that year. A clause on who may be a member had been read as a rule on where a member’s customers may be, and read that way it reaches every member: every network serves customers somewhere, and many serve them abroad. What AFRINIC’s management did to one member in 2020, it can do to any member tomorrow. Cloud Innovation answers each charge on its page Did Cloud Innovation break AFRINIC’s rules?.
Are AFRINIC addresses used outside Africa?
Networks use their addresses where their customers are, on every continent: the internet has no customs posts. Cloud Innovation’s customers are network operators, and they use the addresses it provides where their own customers are, as every network does. Nobody had to discover it: where those addresses are used is published, prefix by prefix, for anyone to read. For a member the question is not where its customers are. It is whether a registry has any say over that, and it has none.
ARIN allows it in writing
ARIN, the registry that serves North America, says so in its own policy manual. Section 9 is headed “Out of Region Use” and begins: “ARIN registered resources may be used outside the ARIN service region.” A network registered with ARIN may serve customers on any continent and break no rule. A member of AFRINIC that serves customers abroad is doing the same thing.
A registry records; it does not route
Where an address is announced lies outside the registry system, by that system’s own description. RFC 7020, which describes it, says: “whether IP addresses are actually announced to the Internet and the manner of their advertisement into the Internet’s routing system are operational considerations outside the scope of the Internet Numbers Registry System”. AFRINIC’s own summary of its 2026 transfer policy says the same of the “Regional” label the policy puts on the addresses AFRINIC has issued: the label does not “Alter operational routing rights” or “Change the day-to-day use of resources”. A registry records which network holds which numbers. The network serves its customers where they are.
What independent researchers said
In August 2021 researchers at the Internet Governance Project, at the Georgia Institute of Technology, examined the attempt by AFRINIC’s management to end Cloud Innovation’s membership. They called AFRINIC’s attack an overreaction to its own past problems, said the principle that addresses may not be used outside the region rests on false premises, and advised AFRINIC to give up the idea that the numbers it allocates cannot be used elsewhere. They had no reason to take Cloud Innovation’s side, and have criticised it too. More voices in AFRINIC criticism.
Does out-of-region use leave Africa short of addresses?
No. AFRINIC is one of only two registries in the world that still have IPv4 addresses to give out: by the Number Resource Organization’s count of 30 June 2026, three of the five had none left. AFRINIC’s own statistics showed 575,232 available on 5 November 2026, and a network in Africa can still ask it for a block. The addresses taken without justification were taken inside AFRINIC: the audit AFRINIC published in January 2021 counts 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses “misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification”. An address in use is not an address withheld. The figures: AFRINIC IPv4 addresses.
What the rule should be
None. Where a network’s customers are is the network’s business, and its customers’. The Bill of Rights of Uniqueness Coordination draws the line: “A Regional Internet Registry exists for one reason: to keep Internet number resources unique. It may record. It may coordinate. It may protect uniqueness. It may not rule.” A registry that records who holds which numbers has done its job. One that tells a network where its customers may be has made itself the guard of a border that does not exist.
What NRS asks for members
- No rule, in any policy, on where a member’s customers may be.
- No member accused, and no membership ended, over where its customers are.
- The addresses a network runs on stay with that network, wherever it serves.
- A registry that records which network holds which numbers, and rules over none of them.
NRS asks these for every member. The nine answers, with each rule in its own words and linked to its source, are on Cloud Innovation’s page on AFRINIC out-of-region use.
NRS on AFRINIC, for members: what AFRINIC is, NRS and AFRINIC, AFRINIC governance, AFRINIC board, AFRINIC CEO, AFRINIC bylaws, AFRINIC AGMM and SGMM, AFRINIC code of conduct, AFRINIC elections, AFRINIC membership fees, AFRINIC and Smart Africa, AFRINIC court cases, AFRINIC receiver, AFRINIC wind-up, AFRINIC IPv4 addresses and AFRINIC criticism.