Number Resource Society
AFRINIC criticism: the members’ case against their registry
Elections annulled, proxies banned, members left off the register, a locked exit: the case NRS makes against AFRINIC for its members, and what it asks.
On this page
AFRINIC criticism comes from researchers and reporters, and from the networks whose addresses it records and whose fees pay for it. Cloud Innovation’s page on AFRINIC criticism collects what independent voices have said, with their sources. Here is the case NRS makes for its members, and what it asks instead.
Every point below can be checked against a court order, a public record or AFRINIC’s own words.
Their votes were thrown away
In June 2025 AFRINIC’s members voted for a Board, and AFRINIC’s Receiver annulled the entire election over one disputed proxy. The rerun of September 2025 banned the proxy voting that Article 12.12 of AFRINIC’s constitution allows. AFRINIC’s Election Guidelines for 2026, approved by its Board on 4 February 2026, say again that proxy voting “shall not be permitted” where elections are conducted virtually. A Board cannot take away by guideline what the constitution gives the members. More in AFRINIC elections.
They are not on the register
AFRINIC is a company, and it belongs to its members: the networks whose addresses it records. Its register of members should name them all. The Registrar of Companies’ record of AFRINIC, issued on 28 October 2026, names eight directors and one company. The networks that sign AFRINIC’s agreement, pay its fees and are supposed to elect its Board are not on it. NRS has asked AFRINIC to enter them: Put AFRINIC’s members on the register.
Court orders are not obeyed
In 2021 the Supreme Court restrained AFRINIC from ending a membership, and the judgment of 19 July 2022 records that an order of the Court was “deliberately flouted” by those then running AFRINIC. In June 2025, on AFRINIC’s own application, the Court ordered a member entered in AFRINIC’s register, and AFRINIC’s Receiver undertook to do it within 15 days. The 15 days passed without rectification. When the entry was made in October 2026, the Receiver asked the Registrar of Companies to remove it, and copied ministers rather than going back to the Court. Every order: AFRINIC court cases.
Their money is spent without account
Before AFRINIC’s annual general members’ meeting of 25 June 2026, NRS asked members to vote against approving the financial statements. They disclose USD 3.29 million in legal expenditure from 2022 to 2025, paid with members’ money, and the invoices, time records and approvals behind it have not been disclosed. Read NRS’s notice of 24 June 2026.
Their way out is locked
Since 4 February 2026, in AFRINIC’s own words, “AFRINIC-issued IPv4 cannot be transferred out of the region”. AFRINIC’s contract makes every member accept that its addresses “are not property”, and lets AFRINIC revoke them when the agreement ends. A member that cannot leave with the addresses AFRINIC issued to it cannot hold its registry to account. More in AFRINIC IPv4 addresses.
The trouble began inside AFRINIC
AFRINIC’s own audit, published in 2021, found 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses “misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification”. That same year researchers at the Internet Governance Project, at the Georgia Institute of Technology, called AFRINIC’s move against a member an overreaction to its own past problems. Researchers, reporters and others who have spoken since are quoted in what others have said.
What NRS asks for members
- An election under the constitution as it is written, with the proxy voting it allows.
- Every eligible resource member in the register of members, with a vote.
- Court orders obeyed, and challenged only in court.
- Members’ money accounted for, invoice by invoice.
- The freedom to change registry and keep the addresses a network runs on.
What researchers and reporters have said about the same questions is collected on Cloud Innovation’s page on AFRINIC criticism.
NRS on AFRINIC, for members: what AFRINIC is, AFRINIC elections, AFRINIC court cases, AFRINIC receiver, AFRINIC wind-up and AFRINIC IPv4 addresses.