Number Resource Society

Lu Heng and AFRINIC: the court fight that protects every member

Through his company, Cloud Innovation, Lu Heng took AFRINIC to court in 2021. What the Supreme Court decided, and what every member gained from it.

NRSFirst published
On this page

Lu Heng’s dispute with AFRINIC has been fought in court since 2021, through his company, and every AFRINIC member has a stake in what was decided. Lu Heng is the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation, a member of AFRINIC since 2013. When AFRINIC’s management moved to put his company out, he took the registry to court through it, and the Supreme Court of Mauritius has ruled for the company again and again. Who he is, and what he says about it in his own words, is set out on Cloud Innovation’s page on Lu Heng and AFRINIC.

He did not set out as an opponent. In one of his Notes he writes: “I did not begin from opposition. I began from participation.” What his company won, it won as a member, and that is why it matters to every member: a member can take its registry to court, and win.

2021: a registry cannot simply switch a member off

In 2021 AFRINIC’s management, and then its Board, moved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership, which would have taken back the addresses its customers’ networks run on. The Judge in Chambers stopped it three times: on 29 March 2021, on 13 July 2021 and on 3 December 2021, when the Court restrained AFRINIC from ending the membership until the dispute is finally decided. For every member, that is the first protection: when a registry tries to put a member out, a court can stop it.

2022: going to court is a member’s right

AFRINIC’s management asked the Court to treat the company’s applications as an abuse of its process. On 19 July 2022 the Court refused: Cloud Innovation “cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights”. Every member has the same right.

2023: a registry that could not govern itself, placed under the Court

By September 2023 AFRINIC had four directors, too few for a board quorum, and no chief executive. On 12 September 2023, on Cloud Innovation’s application, the Supreme Court placed AFRINIC in receivership, to preserve its assets and to see that elections are held under its constitution, and restrained it from relocating, merging, restructuring or submitting to a takeover. AFRINIC belongs to its members; when those running it could no longer govern it, a member asked the Court to protect it, and the Court did. In his words: “Stopping institutional abuse is therefore not disruption. It is system defense.”

2025: a member ordered onto the register

On 11 June 2025, on AFRINIC’s own application, the Supreme Court ordered AFRINIC’s register of members rectified to add Cloud Innovation as its member. After the Court drew up its order as a rule on 9 October 2026, the Registrar of Companies’ record of AFRINIC, issued on 28 October 2026, lists the company as a member from 9 October 2026. The same record names eight directors and that one company: the networks that are supposed to elect AFRINIC’s Board are not on it. NRS asks AFRINIC to enter every eligible resource member, as the Court ordered for one: put AFRINIC’s members on the register.

What every member gained

  • A registry cannot simply switch a member off: a court can stop it, and in 2021 one did, three times.
  • Going to court to protect a member’s rights is not an abuse of process.
  • A registry that can no longer govern itself can be placed under the Court, at a member’s request, to hold elections under its constitution.
  • A member can be ordered onto the register of members. NRS asks the same for every eligible member.

He does not claim to be the only one wronged: “I am certainly not the first victim of this system.” He calls himself “likely the first survivor”. The orders his company obtained are on the public record, for every member to read and to use: AFRINIC court cases.

Who Lu Heng is, why he went to court and what he believes, in his own words and from the record: Lu Heng and AFRINIC.

NRS on AFRINIC, for members: what AFRINIC is, AFRINIC elections, AFRINIC court cases, AFRINIC receiver, AFRINIC wind-up, AFRINIC IPv4 addresses and AFRINIC criticism.

Take part

Registry decisions shape your network. Work with NRS to change how they are made.

Every network runs on rules its operators never wrote. NRS exists to change that. Choose how you stand with us.